Perspectives

According to teachers, some probable causes for disruptive behavior are related to students' inability to socialize with their peers, such as immaturity and untaught material (Duer, 2002).  For this reason, we cannot make assumptions that students have already developed healthy prosocial behaviors; instead we must teach our students these skills.  Dating back to Dewey, my research has shown that social fundamentals in the school are increasingly being viewed as essential.  "There is truth in saying that education must first be human and only after that professional" (Dewey, 1916, p. 225).  Says a principal of 15 years, "It was obvious to me that the standard formula of filling chidren with math and reading skills did little to promote the very behaviors they needed to succeed in those subjects" (Rusnak, 1998, p. 71).

To get pespective from students and teachers at my school regarding how positive of an environment the school is, I used the respect and responsibility school culture survey (see the tab at the top of the homepage.)  The difference in perspective is HUGE (note: the high percentages of students in disagreement with some of the statements, one has high as 52%.) Their results are shown in the tables below...

                                                               ~Teacher perspective~
6 teachers participated
The number after each statement is how many teachers who were in disagreement…
Students treat other students with respect regardless of differences. (0)
Students treat teachers with respect. (0)
Students treat other adults at school with respect. (0)
Students respect others' property. (0)
Teachers treat students with respect. (0)
Other adults at school treat students with respect. (0)
Teachers don't allow students to treat each other disrespectfully. (0)
Teachers don't allow students to treat them disrespectfully. (0)
People in this school are generally polite. (0)
The school has clear rules against hurting other people physically or threatening to hurt. (0)
The schoo has clear rules against hurting other people emotionally. (0)
The school has effective disciplinary consequences for hurting people in any way. (0)
I feel respected at this school. (0)
Students are willing to help other students, even if they are not friends. (0)
Students solve conflicts without insults or fighting. (0)
The school encourages students to perform kind actions. (0)
The school teaches students specific things they can do when they see someone bullying others. (0)
When students do something hurtful, they are required to do something positive to make up for it. (0)
Using mostly the same questions (note: not all of the same questions), I asked for my students' 
perspectives on our school enviornment.  Their results are shown in the table below...

                                                                    ~Student perspective~
86 students (5th, 6th, 7th, & 8th graders) participated
The numbers after each statement is how many students and the percentage of students
who were in disagreement…
Students treat other students with respect regardless of differences. (27 students / 31%)
Students treat teachers with respect. (12 students / 14%)
Students treat other adults at school with respect. (6 students / 7%)
Students respect others' property. (24 students / 28%)
Teachers treat students with respect. (18 students / 21%)
Teachers don't allow students to treat each other disrespectfully. (11 students / 13%)
Teachers don't allow students to treat them disrespectfully. (3 students / 3%)
People in this school are generally polite. (18 students / 21%)
The school has clear rules against hurting other people physically or threatening to hurt.
(2 students / 2%)
The school has clear rules against hurting other people emotionally. (18 students / 21%)
I feel respected at this school. (26 students / 30%)
Students are willing to help other students, even if they are not friends. (27 students / 31%)
Students solve conflicts without insults or fights. (45 students / 52%)
When I see or hear about a student being bullied or hurt in any way, I try to stop it or report it.
(4 students / 5%)
When I see a student being bullied or treated unkindly in any way, I try to comfort them, be their
 friend, give them advice, or help them tell an adult. (1 student / 1%)
If a student reports bullying or any kind of hurtful behavior, a teacher or the school does something
right away to try to stop it. (18 students / 21)
The school teaches student specific things they can do when they see someone bullying others.
(12 students / 14%)
When students do something hurtful, they are required to do something positive to make up for it.
(19 students / 22%)